Modest Mouse Deliver Good Vibes And Birthday Wishes At New York’s Rooftop At Pier 17: Photos + Setlist

TL;DR

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get audio and creator gear delivered free with Prime

• Fast, free delivery on millions of items
• Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
• Member-only deals all year

Start your free Prime trial →Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.Hide

Modest Mouse performed at New York’s Rooftop at Pier 17 on Oct. 8, 2026, on a fall tour supporting An Eraser and a Maze. The show included songs from across the band’s catalog, a crowd-requested “Cowboy Dan” and a birthday call from frontman Isaac Brock to his friend Dave.

Modest Mouse played New York’s Rooftop at Pier 17 on Thursday, Oct. 8, during its fall tour for An Eraser and a Maze, pairing six songs from the new album with material from across the band’s catalog. Frontman Isaac Brock also called his friend Dave onstage to mark Dave’s 86th birthday, while a request from the crowd prompted the band to add “Cowboy Dan” to the set.

In its account of the show, Consequence described Brock as being in good spirits, bantering with the audience and responding to the mood in the room. The report characterized the performance as relaxed, noting that the concert’s atmosphere held up despite a recent lineup change: guitarist Seth Jabour of Les Savy Fav had replaced Simon O’Connor.

The setlist ranged across the group’s releases. It included “King Rat,” “Gravity Rides Everything,” “Missed the Boat,” “Bury Me With It” and “Talking Shit About a Pretty Sunset,” alongside six tracks from the new album, according to the published setlist. “Cowboy Dan” appeared near the end, after Brock agreed to a request from an audience member. The printed setlist had “Shit Luck” as the closer, but Consequence reported that “Cowboy Dan” took its place.

The birthday moment came when Brock remembered that Dave was turning 86 and asked someone offstage to remind him to call. After the next song, Brock used his phone to call Dave and held it up as the audience sang “Happy Birthday” over FaceTime. Consequence reported that Dave appeared to have the phone against his ear and did not see the crowd singing. Brock apologized for taking the audience’s time and said Dave was important to him, adding that Dave helped him with projects.

A Tour Stop With a Personal Moment

The concert offered a snapshot of how Modest Mouse’s current tour is working after a personnel change and while the band supports a new record. Consequence’s report says the lineup played smoothly and describes Brock as engaged with the crowd, but that is the outlet’s assessment of this one performance, not a measure of every show on the tour.

For fans, the night’s appeal was its mix of eras: new-album selections shared space with older and familiar songs. Brock’s decision to add “Cowboy Dan” after a request also made the set feel responsive rather than fixed, while the call to Dave gave the show an unplanned personal interlude. The available report does not establish whether that moment or the changed ending will recur at other tour dates.

The Fall Tour and Lineup Change

Modest Mouse were nearing the end of a fall tour supporting An Eraser and a Maze when they played Pier 17, according to Consequence. The publication noted that the run had drawn questions because guitarist Simon O’Connor had been replaced by Seth Jabour, a member of Les Savy Fav. Its account of the New York date said the change had not prevented the group from delivering a strong performance that night.

The published setlist documents a broad selection, including “Speak ’n Spell (Or Not),” “Life Like Weeds,” “Never Broke,” “The View,” “Never Ending Math Equation” and “Ocean Breathes Salty.” The encore listed “March Into the Sea,” “Life’s a Dream,” “Black Cadillacs” and “Cowboy Dan.” Six songs were identified as tracks from the new album; the source does not name those six individually in its accompanying summary.

““Sorry to take your time with this, but he’s really important to me.””

— Isaac Brock, as quoted in Consequence’s report

What the Setlist Does Not Confirm

The available reporting covers one concert, not the full tour, so it does not establish whether the New York performance reflects the band’s usual form across the run. It also does not give a complete account of how Jabour’s role may affect future performances or whether the lineup will remain the same after the tour.

The setlist account records “Cowboy Dan” in place of “Shit Luck” as the closer, but does not explain whether that change was planned or made entirely in response to the request. The source also does not provide a full setlist comparison with other dates, a recording of the performance or the identity of Dave beyond Brock’s description of him as a friend.

Remaining Dates on the Tour

At the time of Consequence’s report, Modest Mouse had upcoming tour dates remaining, though the supplied source does not list their dates or venues. The report directed readers to the band’s tour listings for ticket information. Further shows may provide a clearer picture of how the new songs, current lineup and setlist choices are developing across the run.

No follow-up plans for Dave’s birthday call, or announcement about the band’s lineup beyond this tour, were included in the report. The next confirmed point of interest is the band’s remaining scheduled performances; specific future setlists and any further lineup updates remain unknown.

Key Questions

When did Modest Mouse play Rooftop at Pier 17?

The band performed at the New York venue on Thursday, Oct. 8, 2026, according to Consequence.

What was the birthday moment?

Frontman Isaac Brock called his friend Dave, who was turning 86, and held up the phone while the audience sang “Happy Birthday” over FaceTime.

Why was “Cowboy Dan” added?

Consequence reported that Brock liked the mood of an audience member who asked for the song and added it to the set. It appeared in place of “Shit Luck,” which the printed setlist had listed as the closer.

Which new album did the tour support?

The fall tour supported An Eraser and a Maze. The Pier 17 set included six tracks from the album, though the source summary does not identify all six by name.

Who played guitar after Simon O’Connor?

Seth Jabour of Les Savy Fav had replaced O’Connor, according to the report. It does not state whether the change is temporary or permanent.

Source: rss